Andy Burnham faced a furious crowd as he was asked about the Greater Manchester Clean Air Zone at a Mayor’s Question Time event this week.
The Labor mayor answered questions from the public at the session which turned into a shouting match on Thursday (February 10) at UA92 in Trafford.
The controversial Clean Air Zone, which was due to come into effect in May but has now been delayed, dominated the event, raising tensions early on.
READMORE:‘What is going to be done now to protect our children’s lungs?’ – Families’ fury over Clean Air Zone delay
BBC presenter Annabel Tiffin lost control of the crowd as members of the public started arguing amongst themselves during the heated discussion.
The scheme was set to charge commercial vehicles which are not compliant with air quality standards every time they drive on the city-region’s roads.
But the government agreed to postpone the deadline by which Greater Manchester’s councils must bring air pollution down to legal limits to 2026.
A ‘substantially different’ scheme is now expected to be revealed by July – and some people have called for the mayor to hold a referendum on the new plans.
One member of the public who was highly critical of the Clean Air Zone at the event on Thursday told Burnham that the whole scheme is ‘anti-democratic’.
He said: “If you don’t hold a referendum, you have no right to be in office.”
Burnham was accused of ‘destroying people’s livelihoods’ and asked how charging businesses would help them to be able to afford cleaner vehicles.
He was also asked why he proposed a Clean Air Zone covering the whole of Greater Manchester and told he must accept he ‘got it wrong and change it’.
Another person claimed Greater Manchester will soon become compliant with legal air quality standards without the Clean Air Zone as vehicles are upgraded.
The mayor told the audience that Greater Manchester council leaders agreed that a ‘Swiss cheese’ model with different rules for each road would not work.
At one point, Burnham reached for a piece of paper in his pocket, saying it proves that government policy was to introduce a charging Clean Air Zone.
He insisted he does not want anybody to pay any Clean Air Zone charges.
But after being continually interrupted, he responded by raising his voice.
He said: “You come in here and assert as if you know everything. But with respect, you don’t know everything.
“You don’t know that I said to the 10 leaders of the Greater Manchester councils last year, ‘we are going to have to go back to the government because in my view and from what I am hearing, this plan is not going to be deliverable’.
“I said that last year because I’d already commissioned the research on what was going on.
“And when the campaign blew up early in the new year, in some ways, I said straight away, ‘well, I understand why there’s a campaign because I have got my own doubts about whether this is deliverable’.
“So you sit there and suggest that you know everything about it, but you don’t know everything about it.”
One younger person in the audience did defend the older, saying Burnham was ‘trying his best’ and blamed the government for the current situation.
Burnham responded, receiving a round of applause from parts of the audience.
He said: “I do take objection to the government imposing this without enough money – as they did with Tier 3 – and then saying, ‘it’s all the mayor, it’s all Greater Manchester’. That is wrong.
“That is not the kind of politics we should have in this country because it’s basically dishonest.
“We’re entitled to fight back a bit here about what’s being done.”
Speaking at a Combined Authority meeting on Friday (February 11), the mayor said he would make a statement about the next steps with the Clean Air Zone.
Sign up to the MEN email newsletters to get the latest on sport, news, what’s on and more by following this link